How to Leave a Review on Etsy : The Complete Guide

how to leave a review on etsy

Omar Founder of OJ Digital Solutions

Table of Contents

Did you purchase an item but don’t know how to leave a review on Etsy?

Don’t know how? I can help you.

In this guide, I’ll provide a step-by-step process for how to leave a review on Etsy. I’ll guide you on how to write, delete, or edit a product review on Etsy—whether you’re on the website or the Etsy app.

I’ll also explain the following:

  • Etsy’s review system
  • Why there seems to be no option to review certain products
  • Why leaving feedback is crucial.

Let’s begin.

Etsy’s Five-Star Review System

You must familiarize yourself with Etsy’s five-star review system before you start writing reviews.

Etsy uses a five-star review system where one star is the lowest score while five is the highest.

Under Etsy’s feedback system, you’re free to allot the stars that best represent your purchase and overall experience with the seller. There’s also a space for text where you can provide additional information regarding your experience.

Write detailed reviews on Etsy if you want to help other shoppers. You can provide details on the following aspects of your experience:

  • Product quality (Is it how the seller described it? Does it match the images on Etsy?)
  • Seller (Is the seller responsive? Did the seller offer a positive experience?)
  • Shipping (Did the product arrive within the estimated delivery date? Did it arrive undamaged?)

If you’re using the Etsy app, you can also give a separate star rating for the following criteria:

  • Shipping
  • Item Quality
  • Seller’s Customer Service

Remember that the star rating you see on Etsy sellers’ pages is an average of all their reviews for the past year. The star rating isn’t a reflection of any particular product.

Why Can’t You Review Some Items on Etsy?

Wondering why there isn’t a “Review this item” option available for specific products even though you want to leave feedback?

Don’t fret.

You can only leave an Etsy review if you meet the following criteria.

  • You made the order with a registered (whether it’s new or existing) account on Etsy.
  • The order is still within Etsy’s 100-day review window, which begins from the order’s estimated delivery date. For digital items, 100 days starts once you download the file.
  • The 100-day window won’t pause even if you have an open case for the order.
  • You can only leave a review on Etsy for orders without an open case.
  • You must purchase the product via Etsy’s website or mobile app.

How to Leave Feedback on Etsy Website

You’ve now learned the Etsy system for leaving reviews. It’s time to use it.

When leaving a review, ensure your feedback focuses only on your experience with the seller. Avoid including any problems with the postal service or shipping company since Etsy shop owners have no control over them.

Follow these steps to leave a review on Etsy via the website.

Go to

From the shop homepage, head to the top right corner and log into your account. If you have multiple Etsy accounts, you can only write a review with the same account you used to purchase the product you want to review.

how to leave a review on etsy

Head To Your Account.

Head to Your Account. Click Purchases and Reviews from the drop-down menu.

word image 50245 3 1

Find the Specific Product.

After clicking Purchases and Reviews, you’ll see all your purchased products with pending reviews.

Find the specific product you want to review.

Once you’ve selected the product, choose a star that best represents how you feel about it.

word image 50245 4 1

Provide details.

A popup will appear after you choose a star rating.

Use the text box to justify your review. Write about your experience with the product and seller and provide as many details as possible.

Writing a detailed review contributes to the Etsy community and helps other buyers make the best possible decision regarding their purchases.

You can also include a picture of the actual item if you want your feedback to be more thorough.

Once satisfied, submit your review by clicking Post Your Review.

word image 50245 5 1

After posting your review, Etsy will show your entire review on the seller’s page and your Purchases page.

How To Leave Reviews on the Etsy App

The Etsy mobile app has a slightly different process to follow if you want to leave a review. The difference lies in the interface of the app.

Follow these steps to write a review on the Etsy app.

Download the Etsy App.

Download the Etsy app on the App Store or Google Play if you haven’t already.

Sign in to your account once the download is complete.

word image 50245 6 1

Tap the You Button.

Tap the You button, then choose Purchases and Reviews.

The number within the green circle refers to the number of items you’ve purchased that don’t have feedback yet.

word image 50245 7 1

Choose the Specific Item.

Choose the item you want to review, then tap Leave a review. If you can’t find this Etsy prompt, the review period for the item may have already expired.

word image 50245 8 1

Provide Details.

If the app allows you to leave a review, it will also ask about your experience with an Etsy shop owner and let you choose how many stars to give.

Etsy rates the seller based on Item Quality, Shipping, and Seller Customer Service. Ticking the “I didn’t need customer service” box will hide Seller Customer Service.

word image 50245 9 1

Use the text box to provide more details about your experience with the Etsy seller relating to the abovementioned criteria.

Post a Photo (Optional).

You also have the option to include a photo on your review via the Etsy app. Choose an existing image from your gallery or take a new photo by tapping on Take a photo.

word image 50245 10 1

Tap Submit when you’re satisfied with your review. The Etsy app will post it immediately.

How To Leave Reviews Without an Etsy Account

What if you don’t have an account with Etsy? Can you leave an Etsy review as a guest?

Etsy doesn’t allow guests (buyers without an account) to leave a review on Etsy. Only a registered Etsy user can leave feedback on the platform. This system ensures all reviews match a verified purchase.

If you want to leave reviews on items purchased using a guest account, you can create an account and claim the purchase.

Here’s how you can claim a purchase:

Open Your Email Account.

Find the message from

The date you placed the order should be the same as the date on the email.

word image 50245 11 1

Click the Order Number.

Look for the confirmation number in the receipt. You can find it under Order details.

Use the image below as a guide.

word image 50245 12 1

Create an Account.

You’d receive an option to create an account if you followed the prompts. Create your account and fill in the necessary information.

Leave A Review.

Etsy will automatically link the order to your new account. You can now leave a review for that specific order. Follow the same steps for leaving a review via desktop or mobile app.

Common Problems and Solutions

Leaving a review using a guest account can lead to the following problems.

You Can’t Locate the Email

Check your junk mail or spam folder if you can’t find the email from in your inbox.

You can also use the search function on your email to find Etsy’s transaction confirmation.

If both solutions don’t work, contact Etsy Support.

Nothing Happens After Clicking the Confirmation Number

If you don’t receive a prompt to create an Etsy account, verify that you’re viewing the correct order receipt.

You might be viewing other notification emails from Etsy, like a message notification from an Etsy shop owner or shipping updates, which don’t have any links to claim your order.

Error Page

If you see an error page, sign out of Etsy.

After signing out, log back into your account. Ensure the account has the same email you used when purchasing as a guest.

If you’re using the browser on your smartphone to claim an order, sign out of the app first.

Here’s how to sign out of Etsy’s mobile app:

  • Step 1: Open the app and tap You.
word image 50245 13 1
  • Step 2: Choose the account Settings.
word image 50245 14 1
  • Step 3: Tap the Sign Out option.
word image 50245 15 1

If it’s your first time buying from Etsy, the best way to avoid any issues is to register an account before completing your purchase.

How To Delete or Edit Review on Etsy

You can edit the photo, text, or star rating or delete your entire review if it’s still within the 100-day review period.

You can’t edit reviews if there’s an open case for the order, though.

You also can’t change a negative review (three stars or lower) once it has the seller’s review response, even if they delete it.

word image 50245 16 1

If you can still edit or delete a review on Etsy, here’s what you need to do.

  • Sign in to your Etsy account.
  • Click the “You” or the account icon.
  • From the dropdown menu, select “Purchases and Reviews.”
  • In your reviews page, find the original review you want to edit and click “Edit review.”
  • Once you’re happy with the changes, select “Post Your Review.”

Why You Should Leave a Review on Etsy

It isn’t only the seller who benefits from Etsy reviews. When you review items on Etsy, you also help fellow shoppers.

Surveys suggest that 95% of customers first read reviews before making a final decision.

Here are reasons you should leave reviews on Etsy.

1. Strengthen the Etsy Community

Every review you leave on Etsy allows you to build meaningful connections with sellers and customers.

If you notice one Etsy user buying the same products, you likely have similar tastes and preferences. If you follow like-minded Etsy users, you’ll gain insights into some products you may not have previously known.

2. Express Your Feeling About the Product

Writing a review on Etsy is the perfect avenue to express how you feel about a product.

Let others feel your joy and enthusiasm if you receive an item on Etsy that exceeds your expectations.

If you receive a poor-quality item, write a review about your annoyance and dissatisfaction. Etsy store owners will always attempt to handle negative reviews professionally because buyers can report any inappropriate review response.

3. Provide Useful Information for Other Etsy Buyers

Positive reviews for a seller reflect good customer service, making other buyers trust that seller.

By contrast, shoppers will be discouraged from buying an item with a negative review.

Whether positive or negative, each review on Etsy will help other buyers make an informed decision.

The Bottom Line

Knowing how to leave a review on Etsy is a pretty straightforward process, whether you’re using a desktop or the Etsy app.

I hope my guide has made it easier for you to understand how to write, delete, or edit a review on Etsy.

Make it a habit to leave a positive review for every successful purchase, even on other online marketplaces. When you leave a review on Etsy with thoughtful feedback, you make a seller’s day and simplify buyers’ lives.

If you bought an item on Etsy recently, here’s how you can track your order.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get A Quick Response For Your Desired Service

Fill out the form below and we will get back to you as soon as possible.